Friday, September 13, 2013
2008 2011 Jeep Liberty Dodge Nitro
Introduction: The Jeep Liberty is the successor to the old Jeep Cherokee. However in much of the world it still retains the old Cherokee name. The Liberty features the uni body on ladder frame construction which stiffens its ride and handling. The Liberty is easily one of Jeeps trail rated vehicles meaning its been tested by Jeep for its ability to go off road. The Dodge Nitro was introduced in 2007 as Dodges newest compact SUV since the 1990s when they had the Raider which was a Mitsubishi Pajero. The second generation Liberty in 2008 uses the same platform and borrowed the styling of the Nitro as well.
By the point Ive driven the two, I was pretty unsatisfied with Chrysler I wasnt expecting these two to be any good.
Performance: There isnt a single change since the old Liberty, it still uses the same 3.7L PowerTech V6. There hasnt even been a performance upgrade from last time so its still 210 hp and 235 lb.ft of torque. It still sounds awful and its still slow, both cars take at least 10 seconds to reach 100 km/h from a standstill. Fuel economy is still rubbish. Keep in mind this engine much like it was in 2001 on a 2002 Liberty, a decade of no change.
My Score: 2/10 - The engine by this stage is very old, still extremely slow and has pathetic fuel economy thats the reason the score went down.
Handling: Not much has changed here either, both cars have pretty heavy steering but its not direct like a BMW. Its actually rather vague, making each turn feel meaningless. Ride comfort as expected is still bad, and due to their weight and height neither is very good on corners. Since these are supposed to be taken off road I cant deduct too many points but for sure these two arent very good on the road.
My Score: 4/10 - Same as last time, steering is distant, the ride comfort is poor and it has no agility.
Interior: The interior of both vehicles have been designed when Daimler Chrysler still existed, as a result both are pretty poorly done. Interior room is surprisingly poor for the driver and passenger. Im actually a short guy but I felt cramped every time I drove one of these. It seems as if Chrysler forgot where the drivers legs were supposed to go. Rear seating isnt very impressive for an SUV of this size. The previous Liberty had its spare tire on the back, this new Liberty puts it in the vehicle which takes up a bit of tailgate space, unfortunately you dont gain anything from this as the rear window is still too small. The rest of the interior is composed of very cheap plastic and the atmosphere is as dark and depressing as other Chrysler vehicles. The build quality on these vehicles is generally alright, sometimes there are squeaks and rattles though. The only major changes made to the 2011 vehicles is the steering wheel has been changed to the new Grand Cherokee style wheel, cruise control is now button operated instead of the very flimsy plastic lever from before. Both vehicles are assembled in Toledo, Ohio in the United States.
My Score: 2/10 - Cramped drivers space, terrible interior materials, less space than the previous Liberty.
Styling: Theres not much to say about either vehicle, theyre both extremely square. Both seemed to have been styled with cubes in mind. This unfortunately doesnt really make either that interesting. Theyre not exactly ugly, but theyre both rather unimaginative. This is worse than before I find.
My Score: 2/10 - Square and dull.
Value for money: The old Libertys saving grace was its a 4-door off roading SUV. I absolutely understood that it had some value back then. This is no longer the case anymore Im afraid and even worse for Chrysler this competition is created by themselves. Theres a Jeep Wrangler available in a 4-door configuration, if there was a Jeep to pick for off roading the Wrangler is so much better. It looks like a real Jeep, its made like a real Jeep and it has real Jeep features. The Liberty has none of those things. The Nitro honestly serves no purpose either for Dodge, as most Chrysler dealerships hold all three Chrysler brands. I honestly cant see a real reason to pick a Liberty over a Wrangler in the one area it was supposed to be good at. As a road SUV its absolutely horrible and there are several other choices guaranteed to be better. Its now horrible value for money.
My Score: 2/10 - The Jeep Wrangler took away its only saving grace last time, its utterly pointless now.
Overall: 12/50 - These SUVs are awful and with a 4-door Wrangler available serve no purpose.
